Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Pochettino faces uphill task to revive Manchester United, says Guardian's Unwin

Ahead of his first game in charge at Anfield, Mauricio Pochettino's prospects of turning around Manchester United were assessed by the Guardian's Will Unwin in a reader Q&A.

Photograph: Manchester United v Everton, 2 October 2021 (28)

Mauricio Pochettino prepares for his opening match as Manchester United head coach away to Liverpool at Anfield, taking charge of a club mired in a lengthy run of managerial upheaval.

Answering reader questions for Guardian Football, the paper's Will Unwin said United's academy could offer Pochettino an alternative if senior players fail to deliver the high-pressing, attacking approach he favours.

Unwin noted that under previous head coach Michael Carrick, United often looked more effective on the counterattack, even though that style sits uneasily with the club's traditional attacking identity.

Pochettino has spoken of his admiration for Sir Alex Ferguson and said on Thursday that he wants his team to be "protagonists" on the pitch, a sign he intends to honour that attacking legacy rather than retreat into caution.

Unwin said it could take several months before it becomes clear whether Pochettino has a more pragmatic fallback plan, adding that he personally would favour sticking with counterattacking football, though he doubted the new head coach would take his advice.

Asked what separates Pochettino from predecessors including David Moyes, Louis van Gaal, José Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjær and Ruben Amorim, Unwin said no single trait clearly set him apart. Like Van Gaal, Mourinho and Amorim, Pochettino is self-assured, and a defined coaching philosophy did not guarantee any of them success either.

Unwin argued Pochettino was simply the strongest available candidate given his track record in English football and his experience leading a long-term rebuilding project at Tottenham Hotspur. He suggested Pochettino's handling of relationships with players and club hierarchy, including dealings with Donald Trump during his time with the United States men's national team, could prove an underrated asset.

On whether United can realistically expect success soon, Unwin said the club's current squad lacks the depth and quality to cope with the demands of competing in the Premier League and Champions League simultaneously, meaning this season should probably be written off beyond stabilising results.

He said further squad rebuilding is required beyond the change of head coach, with director of football Jason Wilcox and chief executive Omar Berrada facing scrutiny over recent transfer business, despite retaining the backing of co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe. Unwin said United have long struggled to find value for money in the transfer market, leaving any coach short of the resources a club with United's history should command.

Addressing claims that Pochettino remains an elite manager, Unwin pointed to his spells at Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea, where he worked with high-calibre players without winning major trophies, as well as a period coaching the USMNT. At 54, Unwin said, this represents what is likely Pochettino's last chance at a major Premier League job, and he will need to strike a new balance between his attacking principles and a squad that has struggled playing on the front foot.

Photo credits

File photo (2021). Photo: Ardfern · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails