Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Pochettino's Chelsea spell offers clues to Manchester United test

Analysis of Mauricio Pochettino's one season at Chelsea provides the clearest guide to what Manchester United can expect from the Argentinian, according to Guardian Football reporting on Opta data.

Brentford v Chelsea - FA Cup - Jan 2013 - The TV Pundit Panel

Mauricio Pochettino's single season in charge of Chelsea stands as the most useful comparison for what Manchester United might see under him, according to Guardian Football, which examined Opta statistics from his managerial career.

Pochettino is rated among the Premier League's elite by points-per-game average, trailing only Alex Ferguson, Arsène Wenger, José Mourinho, Jürgen Klopp and Pep Guardiola among the 20 managers with more than 290 league matches. He lifted Southampton to eighth place in his only full season there and took Tottenham to second, third and a Champions League final during his time at the club.

But he has managed in only one of the last six Premier League campaigns, and his spell winning Ligue 1 and the Coupe de France with Paris Saint-Germain offers little guidance for United. His 2023-24 season at Chelsea is considered more instructive.

Chelsea had finished 12th the previous year, in the opening season of the Todd Boehly and Clearlake Capital ownership. Opta had forecast a sixth-place finish for Pochettino's side, and that is exactly where Chelsea ended up. Transfermarkt had rated the squad's market value as the third-highest in the Premier League that October, meaning Pochettino arguably matched expectations rather than exceeded them, despite Chelsea having spent more than any other club in Europe's top five leagues across three consecutive transfer windows.

Chelsea's underlying numbers from that campaign were volatile. The side generated the fifth-highest expected points total in the division, at 63.4, behind Arsenal's 81.2, Manchester City's 79.3 and Liverpool's 76.2. They conceded 63 league goals, their worst total of the Premier League era, while also scoring 77, a figure bettered only twice in the club's history. Chelsea benefited from 12 penalties, the joint-second-most of any side in the past decade of the competition, and conceded five themselves, while committing the joint-most Opta-defined defensive errors leading to shots, with 22.

The swings in form were stark. Across three matches in April 2024, Chelsea drew 2-2 with bottom club Sheffield United, beat Everton 6-0 and then lost 5-0 at Arsenal. Earlier in the season they lost 4-1 at both Tottenham and Newcastle either side of a 4-4 draw with Manchester City. Chelsea also set a Premier League record for a 38-game season by scoring and conceding at least two goals in 12 matches.

The lowest point, Guardian Football notes, came after Chelsea lost the 2024 Carabao Cup final, when Gary Neville described the squad as "billion-pound bottle jobs". Pochettino left the club within three months of that defeat.

Since his departure, the competition has shifted further, with Arne Slot winning the title with Liverpool before departing and Guardiola also leaving Manchester City, removing the last of the division's dominant long-serving managers. Increased man-to-man marking and the growing influence of set pieces have altered how matches are decided.

Opta's data suggests Pochettino's likely Manchester United side will move the ball forward more quickly than his Chelsea team did, though with less intense pressing, pointing to tactical adjustments ahead. Guardian Football also reports that a well-placed source described his training methods at Chelsea as "antiquated", raising questions over how quickly he can adapt at United, even as his overall Premier League record continues to command respect.

Photo credits

File photo (2013). Photo: Gareth Williams from Redhill, England · CC BY 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons