Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Carrick sacking exposes years of muddled decision-making at Manchester United

Guardian Football's analysis of Michael Carrick's dismissal traces a pattern of confused hierarchy at Old Trafford stretching back to the Ferguson era, with Eddie Howe's belated emergence as a leading candidate the latest example.

Manchester United v Watford (1-0), Premier League, Old Trafford, Manchester, Greater Manchester, England, 13 May 2018. Michael Carrick's final match.

Michael Carrick's sacking as Manchester United head coach has been described by Guardian Football as the latest symptom of a dysfunctional hierarchy at Old Trafford rather than simply a managerial failure.

The 45-year-old leaves with United in the Premier League relegation zone, having taken eight points from 10 league matches and won only two of 12 games in all competitions this season, a run that also included elimination from the Carabao Cup.

Eddie Howe has emerged as a leading candidate to replace him, a decision recommended to owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe by Jason Wilcox, now the club's highest-ranking football executive. Guardian Football notes the irony: Wilcox rejected Howe as a candidate nearly two years ago when the former Newcastle manager was instead the choice of Dan Ashworth, Wilcox's predecessor as director of football, to replace Erik ten Hag following his sacking in October 2024. Ratcliffe backed Wilcox's preference for Ruben Amorim at the time, and Ashworth left the club just five months after being appointed.

Should Howe be confirmed, he would become United's eighth permanent manager since Sir Alex Ferguson retired 13 and a half years ago.

Guardian Football draws a comparison with José Mourinho, who managed United from May 2016 to December 2018 under a hierarchy led by then executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward. Mourinho called finishing second in the 2017-18 season, 19 points behind champions Manchester City, one of his finest achievements given the environment he was working in. He had already delivered the Carabao Cup and Europa League in his first season.

The analysis also highlights friction inside Carrick's dressing room in his final weeks. Lisandro Martínez was reported to have criticised Wilcox's recruitment after a 2-0 defeat by Atlético Madrid, while Bruno Fernandes questioned his manager's tactics following a 4-1 loss at Como. Guardian Football describes both incidents as emblematic of a chaotic squad environment that undermined results.

There is a contrast with Carrick's earlier spell as interim head coach last season, when from mid-January he beat Manchester City, Arsenal, Liverpool and Chelsea and lost only two of 17 games. Guardian Football says that record make this season's collapse particularly stark.

Carrick's popularity with supporters was underlined by the reception he received from the Stretford End during a 3-0 defeat by Bournemouth last month.

Guardian Football points to the club's ownership structure as the root of the instability, with Ratcliffe holding 29.4% and the Glazer family's ownership since 2005 leaving United around £1.2bn in debt. The piece also recalls that Louis van Gaal, one of Carrick's predecessors, was sacked the day after winning the 2016 FA Cup, underlining what it calls a recurring pattern of incoming managers inheriting unresolved problems from above.

Photo credits

File photo (2018). Photo: Ardfern · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails