Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Manchester United fans vent fury and despair over Carrick sacking

Guardian Football readers responding to Michael Carrick's dismissal at Manchester United blamed ownership, recruitment and a pattern of short-termism stretching back more than a decade.

Photograph: Manchester United v Everton, 2 October 2021 (28)

Michael Carrick's sacking as Manchester United manager drew an outpouring of frustration from supporters, with many telling Guardian Football that the real problem at Old Trafford lies far beyond the dugout.

One reader, Chris, who has followed the club since the early 1990s, called Carrick "the only likable thing about the club" and said fans attending matches, including a recent FA Cup tie against Brighton, had endured a toxic atmosphere. "The fans deserve better," the reader wrote, adding that supporters needed "better owners, better attitudes, better standards".

A reader identified as Deb placed responsibility on the club's hierarchy, writing that the director of football Jason Wilcox, chief executive Omar Berrada and co-owner Jim Ratcliffe "should have fired themselves" and describing them as "the common denominator of all this failure". The same reader predicted Mauricio Pochettino, reportedly under consideration as Carrick's successor, would not last long in the role.

Barry, a United supporter of more than 60 years, said the club had ignored obvious needs in defence while instead recruiting midfielders, and questioned whether changing manager again would alter anything.

Other readers pointed to the club's managerial history since Alex Ferguson's retirement. One contributor, Simon, noted that United have had 12 managers, including caretakers, since Ferguson left, arguing this pointed to failures running through every level of the organisation.

A reader called Jason drew a parallel with Ole Gunnar Solskjær's elevation from caretaker to permanent manager, arguing Carrick had been promoted on the same flawed logic. The same reader suggested United had previously dismissed managers such as Ralf Rangnick and Ruben Amorim for warning that results might worsen before improving, and said there was no reason to expect different treatment for Pochettino.

Another reader, Paul, compared the Glazer family's ownership of United to ENIC's long tenure at Tottenham Hotspur, warning that United faced a similarly bleak outlook. That reader argued the comparison was worse for United because Tottenham's debts had at least funded a new stadium rather than enabling dividends to owners.

A supporter named Robert, writing that United's current squad was "completely below average quality", said the club was "completely broken" and blamed an "appallingly negligent transfer window" for undermining Carrick before the season had begun.

A separate reader also called Paul, who said he had supported United for more than 70 years, said he could no longer back the club while the Glazers remained in charge, suggesting an empty Old Trafford through a fan boycott might be the only way to force them out.

Photo credits

File photo (2021). Photo: Ardfern · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails