Manchester United's crisis runs deeper than the manager, Guardian Football argues
An analysis by Guardian Football traces Manchester United's collapse from third place last season to one of their worst runs, arguing the problems sit far above head coach Michael Carrick.

Manchester United's season has unravelled from a third-place Premier League finish last term into one of the worst runs of form in the club's history, Guardian Football said in an assessment of the crisis at Old Trafford.
Head coach Michael Carrick remains in post despite performances that, the outlet said, suggest he has effectively given up on the project internally, even as results continue to deteriorate.
Guardian Football said United's reluctance to remove Carrick stems partly from hope of a turnaround, partly from a wish to avoid a compensation payout, and partly because the executives who appointed him cannot agree on a replacement.
The report argued that sacking Carrick would also implicate chief executive Omar Berrada and football director Jason Wilcox, who it said failed to properly support him by not replacing outgoing fitness and set-piece coaches or scrutinising his tactical approach before appointing him.
Co-owner Jim Ratcliffe was described as holding final say over footballing decisions at the club despite not delivering the 'best in class' executives he had promised, with the report noting job cuts and disputes with supporters over ticketing have accompanied his period of influence.
Guardian Football said the Glazer family continue to draw dividends from the club while United's transfer strategy follows a repeating pattern: missed Champions League qualification leads to restricted spending, an unsuitable manager is hired, qualification is eventually achieved through an unsustainable style, and the manager is then denied funds before being dismissed at a cost exceeding earlier savings.
On the pitch, the outlet described a squad that is unfit and lacking collective mentality, with the captain said to have reached breaking point after being repeatedly misled by the club, and players reported to resent the club's executive hierarchy.
The analysis questioned whether even elite coaches such as Eddie Howe, Julian Nagelsmann or Mauricio Pochettino could succeed at Old Trafford given the current structural chaos, framing the issue less as who should replace Carrick than whether anyone could manage United effectively at all.
Photo credits
File photo (2021). Photo: Ardfern · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails