Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Wilson: USMNT faces hard sell finding Pochettino successor

Guardian Football's Jonathan Wilson says the United States will struggle to lure a top European coach to replace Mauricio Pochettino, while also weighing in on Pep Guardiola, Manchester City and Italy's Nations League form.

Mauricio Pochettino on the touchline during a USMNT match
AI-generated illustration

Guardian Football's Jonathan Wilson has said the United States Soccer Federation faces a difficult task persuading a leading European-based coach to take charge of the men's national team as it searches for a successor to Mauricio Pochettino.

Writing in his Soccer Desk column, Wilson argued that the Concacaf Nations League, the Gold Cup and even the 2028 Copa América hold limited appeal for a coach with European ambitions, with the 2030 World Cup still some way off.

He pointed out the last two World Cups were won by lower-profile coaches promoted from within their own federations, who had already worked with much of the squad at youth level, suggesting that model may suit the United States better than an expensive foreign appointment who could later be tempted away by a European offer.

Guardiola and the international game

Asked about United States interest in Pep Guardiola, who has also held talks with Italy, Wilson said club and international management were related but distinct jobs. Club coaches can drill a squad daily to embed a system, he noted, whereas international managers get only a handful of training sessions a year plus major tournaments, making the international game less sophisticated and more reliant on individual quality.

He added that at the last World Cup, nations with high-profile managers - England, Brazil, the United States and Germany - fared worse than federations that had appointed technocrats from within.

Responding to a reader who cited Michael Carrick's dismissal as evidence of a shortage of top English coaches, Wilson said development schemes such as the elite player performance plan and England DNA project had produced far more technically proficient players over the past decade, reflected in improved tournament results, but St George's Park had yet to produce a similar uplift in coaching talent.

He also argued English coaches who succeed at promoted clubs are often judged unsuitable for elite jobs, citing Scott Parker, Gary O'Neil and Eddie Howe as examples of managers overlooked in favour of candidates with European experience.

On sympathy for Manchester City players facing what a reader called a lost season, Wilson said he felt greater sympathy for players at rival clubs whose success had been denied by City's conduct, naming Arsenal and Aston Villa as clubs whose development had been undermined by City signing their best players on wages and fees it should not have been able to offer.

Italy's Nations League form

On Italy, Wilson said recent Nations League results - a home win over France and two victories over Turkey - were not enough to declare the team back on the world stage, noting the question preceded Italy's 4-1 defeat to Belgium. He said Italy had looked sharper under Roberto Mancini than at any point since winning the European Championship under him five years ago, but added they must still qualify for the 2030 World Cup and reach at least the quarter-finals, while Serie A remains well below its former standard.