Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Boxing & MMA

Amazon's Muhammad Ali drama The Greatest falls short, review finds

A review by Guardian Boxing says Amazon Prime Video's eight-part Muhammad Ali series is competently made but adds little to a story told many times before.

DAVOS/SWITZERLAND, 28JAN06 - FLTR: Muhammad Ali, Former Heavyweight-Boxing Champion, Greatest of All Time (GOAT), USA, captured at the Presentation of the Crystal Awards at the Annual Meeting 2006 of the World Economi…

Amazon Prime Video has released The Greatest, an eight-episode drama covering the early career of Muhammad Ali, but a review published by Guardian Boxing concludes the series is a missed opportunity despite strong individual performances.

Described as the first authorised scripted account of Ali's life, the show is backed as executive producer by his widow, Lonnie Ali. Guardian Boxing's review notes the series draws heavily on a biography written by Ali's brother, Rahaman Ali, who died last year aged 82 and is given a dedication in the seventh episode.

The narrative covers four years, from Cassius Clay Jr's light-heavyweight gold medal at the 1960 Rome Olympics to his world heavyweight title upset over Sonny Liston at the age of 22, stopping before Ali's public conversion to Islam. Showrunner Ben Watkins splits focus between Clay and his brother Rudy, played by newcomer Kai Parham.

The review praises several supporting performances, singling out Omari Hardwick as Cassius Clay Sr, Michael Ealy as Malcolm X and Hill Harper as Elijah Muhammad. Amin Joseph's portrayal of Sonny Liston is highlighted as the standout, with the review suggesting the troubled champion would have made a compelling subject for his own series.

Jaalen Best, cast as the young Clay, is judged less successful, with the review arguing the scripts lean too heavily on anxiety and self-doubt rather than the brash self-belief that defined the real fighter. It also finds the in-ring fight choreography unconvincing compared with the domestic scenes involving Clay and his mother, Odessa, played by Dana Gourrier.

Guardian Boxing credits the soundtrack, overseen with input from Jay-Z, as one of the series' genuine strengths, citing a transition from Donny Hathaway's I Believe to My Soul into Wu-Tang Clan's One of These Days.

The central criticism of the review is structural: by keeping Clay as the clear lead rather than committing to Rudy's perspective, the series fails to offer a fresh angle on a life already covered extensively in film and literature, including Will Smith's Oscar-nominated turn in Ali and Eli Goree's performance in One Night in Miami.

The review concludes that readers and viewers already familiar with Ali's story are better served returning to the written record than watching this retelling. The Greatest is available now on Amazon Prime Video.

Photo credits

File photo (2006). Photo: World Economic Forum from Cologny, Switzerland · CC BY-SA 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails