Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Scotland's heavy loss to Switzerland sharpens doubts over Pocognoli

A 4-0 Nations League defeat in St Gallen has intensified scrutiny of Sébastien Pocognoli's tactics, with Guardian Football reporting the head coach's rigid system is struggling to fit his squad just six games into the job.

The tartan army in Munich Germany for the opening match of the 2024 European championship

Scotland's 4-0 defeat by a second-string Switzerland side has deepened concerns over Sébastien Pocognoli's suitability as head coach, with the Belgian only six games into his tenure, according to Guardian Football.

The result left Pocognoli's methods under fresh scrutiny after his Nations League campaign produced just five goals in six matches, four of them against North Macedonia, with three games ending goalless for Scotland. The team has conceded ten goals overall, exposing weaknesses against set pieces and in open play.

Guardian Football reported that Pocognoli's insistence on a 3-4-2-1 formation does not suit the players available to him. Scotland's wingers are said to be poorly deployed within the system, there is a lack of recognised centre-backs despite the coach regularly selecting three, and the midfield lacks balance.

The report noted that no single player has consistently impressed under Pocognoli so far, and that his commitment to what he calls a "philosophy" has raised concerns given there is no transfer window in international football to reshape the squad to fit it.

Pocognoli arrived in the role after winning the title at Union Saint-Gilloise in Belgium and a brief spell at Monaco, but had managed only just over 100 games before taking the Scotland job. Guardian Football suggested the Scottish Football Association may have erred in not appointing a coach with experience managing a nation of comparable scale.

The comparison drawn is with Steve Clarke, who endured difficult early results including successive 4-0 defeats by Belgium and Russia in 2019 before leading Scotland to three of four major tournaments. Unlike Clarke, Pocognoli does not yet have a body of work to suggest he can adapt, the report said.

There is no suggestion the Scottish FA is considering removing Pocognoli at this stage, with Guardian Football noting such a move would be premature and would amount to an admission of failure the governing body is reluctant to make.

Pocognoli was not with the Scotland squad when it flew back to Glasgow from Zurich, with his family remaining in Belgium. The next test comes with next month's draw for Uefa Euro 2028 qualifying, where Scotland will be seeded in pot three. England, Scotland, Wales and the Republic of Ireland are co-hosts, and only two qualifying places are available to any of those nations who do not otherwise qualify. Guardian Football said failing to reach a tournament staged partly in Glasgow would represent a significant setback for the Scottish FA, with competitive fixtures in March, depending on the draw, set to demand marked improvement from Pocognoli's side.

Photo credits

File photo (2024). Photo: Monthejags · CC0 · via Wikimedia Commons