Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Pochettino inherits Manchester United's cycle of sackings and short-term fixes

Mauricio Pochettino takes charge for the first time away to Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday, with Guardian Football analysis questioning whether a new-manager bounce can break Manchester United's pattern of ritual dismissals.

Photograph: Manchester United v Everton, 2 October 2021 (28)

Mauricio Pochettino takes his first match in charge of Manchester United away to Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday, stepping into a dugout that has become one of the most unstable in English football.

Analysis from Guardian Football traces a familiar arc at United: performances fade, results falter, and the response is almost always the same. Michael Carrick's dismissal, the piece argues, looked inevitable from the moment United lost at Hull on the opening weekend, just as his predecessor Ruben Amorim's position was effectively doomed after being filmed adjusting a tactics board in the rain at Grimsby.

The Guardian Football analysis, written by Jonathan Wilson, notes that Carrick was widely regarded as far from the club's biggest problem, raising the question of what his sacking was actually meant to achieve.

The piece places United's pattern within a wider football culture in which sacking the manager has become almost automatic once a club is judged to be in crisis. It draws a comparison with Antonio Conte's complaints at Tottenham Hotspur, where he questioned why he should face scrutiny over the club's direction when he held far less power than the layers of executives above him.

Wilson's analysis links the outsized status of the British football manager to the post-war era of figures such as Matt Busby, Bill Shankly, Don Revie and Brian Clough, citing Barney Ronay's book The Manager, which argues that boards found it useful to have a visible figure to blame when things went wrong.

On whether sacking a manager actually works, the piece cites evidence that early data suggesting the 'new manager bounce' was a statistical illusion has since been challenged. More recent studies referenced in the analysis found that around a quarter of clubs see no improvement after a change, but that points per game rise by 41% on average across the first five matches under a new manager, with the effect fading after roughly ten games.

Pochettino is described in the analysis as a more charismatic and ebullient figure than Carrick, whose uncertain long-term status, it suggests, may have affected how seriously players took his instructions.

The piece cautions, however, that Pochettino inherits what it calls a mismatched squad built up under six previous managers, with no settled style of play yet apparent that would suit the majority of the group.

Photo credits

File photo (2021). Photo: Ardfern · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails