Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

NWSL scraps criteria list for High Impact Player rule after union grievance

The league has settled a grievance with its Players Association over the so-called Rodman Rule, letting clubs spend extra salary-cap money on any player rather than those meeting a fixed list of global-recognition criteria.

Trinity Rodman of Washington Spirit, the player whose name was attached to the NWSL's High Impact Player rule
AI-generated illustration

The NWSL has revised its High Impact Player rule, announcing on Friday that it had settled a grievance with the NWSL Players Association over the policy informally known as the Rodman Rule, according to Guardian Football.

The union had argued that the original criteria for the rule breached federal labor law. Under the change, clubs no longer need a player to meet any of the eight previous qualifying categories before spending additional money on them above the salary cap.

The rule was introduced last winter and quickly nicknamed after Washington Spirit forward Trinity Rodman, seen as a response to concerns she might leave for Europe, potentially to London City Lionesses, another club owned by Spirit owner Michele Kang.

Its original criteria included appearing on SportsPro Media's list of the 150 Most Marketable Athletes, ESPN's Top 50, the Guardian's top 100, the Ballon d'Or 30-player list, leading US national team minutes, or winning NWSL's MVP or Best XI awards.

Only Alessia Russo and Aitana Bonmatí made the 2026 SportsPro list, though sixteen women's players featured in 2025, including three then in the NWSL: Rodman, Sophia Wilson and Marta.

Under the revised structure, clubs that reach the 2027 salary cap of $4.4m (£3.3m) can still spend an additional $1.257m on a player, a figure reported by ESPN, but that money can now go to any player a club chooses rather than one meeting the old criteria.

The shift is expected to help players who missed out under the previous system, including Ashley Sanchez, who fell short of the criteria despite being considered an elite performer, and Catarina Macario, who has dealt with long-running injury problems.

Guardian Football noted the earlier rule had, in effect, risked encouraging a single dominant NWSL roster capable of competing directly with Europe's best-funded sides, such as Chelsea, Lyon and Barcelona, which often spend several times more than NWSL clubs.

The piece drew a comparison with this year's Ballon d'Or, where Barcelona's women won all but one available award. Alexia Putellas collected her third main prize despite having moved to a London club, while Barcelona striker Ewa Pajor, who plays for only one leading team, finished just short.

Washington Spirit, whose roster had been well placed to benefit from the original criteria, host Chicago on Sunday with their stadium expected to be full as they look to secure a top-four finish heading into the post-season.