Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

US Sports

Watson, Rodgers and Prescott top ranking of NFL's most disliked quarterbacks

The Sporting News has compiled a list of the NFL's 25 most scorned starting and backup quarterbacks, led by Cleveland's Deshaun Watson, Pittsburgh's Aaron Rodgers and Dallas's Dak Prescott.

Green Bay Packers quarterback, Aaron Rodgers, after a game against the Washington Football Team at Lambeau Field in Green Bay, Wisconsin on October 24, 2021.

A new ranking published by The Sporting News, via Yahoo Sports, places Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson at the top of the league's most disliked passers, ahead of Pittsburgh Steelers veteran Aaron Rodgers and Dallas Cowboys starter Dak Prescott.

The list weighs on-field performance against off-field perception, factoring in team success, individual statistics, public persona and the volume of media and fan reaction a quarterback generates.

Watson, who began the season 2-1 with one poor outing, one strong performance and one unremarkable display, is said to still be judged against the scale of his large contract following his trade to Cleveland. The piece also notes that allegations from his time with the Houston Texans continue to shape outside opinion of him, regardless of his attempts to rebuild his reputation.

Rodgers, now with the Steelers, is described as having undergone a dramatic shift in public image since leaving the Green Bay Packers, where he was a four-time Most Valuable Player and a mainstream advertising face. The ranking attributes his fall in popularity to his unconventional health views and his repeated public criticism of former teams and relationships, even while rating him among the game's most talented passers.

Prescott's position reflects the built-in hostility that comes with quarterbacking the Cowboys, according to the ranking, with rival fans of the Philadelphia Eagles, New York Giants and Washington Commanders cited as a natural source of dislike. The report also notes frustration among some Dallas supporters over the gap between Prescott's regular-season passing numbers and the team's postseason results, while stressing his standing as one of the league's most respected figures off the field.

Cleveland's Shedeur Sanders is ranked fourth, with the report attributing some of the resentment toward him to the perception that he remains behind Watson on the depth chart while drawing outsized attention, as well as lingering spillover from his father Deion Sanders' reputation.

Washington's Jayden Daniels sits fifth, with the ranking pointing to growing concern in the capital that durability issues could follow a path similar to former Commanders quarterback Robert Griffin III, compounded by scrutiny from an offseason controversy involving his jersey number at Louisiana State University.

Atlanta Falcons quarterback Tua Tagovailoa appears next on the list, which cites a perceived lack of accountability for on-field struggles dating back to his college career at Alabama, along with past comments attributed to former teammates, as reasons for his inclusion.

Photo credits

File photo (2021). Photo: All-Pro Reels · CC BY-SA 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails