Pochettino arrival fits United's pattern of late managerial calls, argues Wilson
Guardian Football columnist Jonathan Wilson argues Mauricio Pochettino's move to Manchester United continues a club habit of hiring managers whose best moment had already passed.

Mauricio Pochettino's arrival at Manchester United reads like the latest instalment of a familiar pattern, according to Guardian Football columnist Jonathan Wilson, who argues the club keeps answering the question of who would have been the ideal manager several years ago rather than who suits the job now.
Wilson traces the habit back to 2013, when José Mourinho's name first circulated as Sir Alex Ferguson prepared to retire. Mourinho has since claimed he turned the job down; other accounts describe him furious in a Madrid hotel on hearing David Moyes had been chosen instead, reportedly because senior board figure Sir Bobby Charlton feared the impact Mourinho might have on the club's image.
By the time Mourinho did take charge in 2016, Wilson writes, his final months at Chelsea had left him weary and tactically exposed, and doubts that had surfaced during his last year at Real Madrid had multiplied. United, in his assessment, were hiring a manager already past his peak rather than the dominant figure of 2013.
Moyes himself, backed by Ferguson's immense authority, might have been the better fit six or seven years before he actually got the job, Wilson suggests, noting that modern managers tend to peak in their mid-to-late 40s.
Louis van Gaal's appointment at 62, fresh from a Dutch title with AZ Alkmaar and a strong 2014 World Cup with the Netherlands, is framed differently as the hiring of an elder statesman rather than a long-term solution, though Wilson notes the expectation he would bring calm sat awkwardly with his actual temperament.
Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim arrived as men supposedly on the rise rather than the decline, the column recalls. Ten Hag's Ajax side had beaten Juventus and Real Madrid in the Champions League and come within a Lucas Moura hat-trick of reaching the final, while Amorim had ended Sporting's 19-year wait for a league title.
Both, in Wilson's account, were undone by circumstance at United: Ten Hag appeared overwhelmed by the scale of the job, while Amorim's insistence on a 3-4-2-1 system with a squad unsuited to it was among the reasons then sporting director Dan Ashworth raised concerns before his own departure.
Pochettino's arrival, Wilson's column suggests, extends that same theme of timing misjudged, with the Argentinian's most compelling case for the role arguably having existed earlier in his career rather than at the point United have turned to him.
Wilson leaves open the possibility that no appointment could succeed at Old Trafford in its current state, describing the club's recent history as one in which the job itself may be set up to damage any manager's reputation, regardless of when he arrives.
Photo credits
File photo (2021). Photo: Ardfern · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails