Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Carrick becomes latest Manchester United manager undone by club's own history

Guardian Football traces a century of Manchester United dysfunction, from Wilf McGuinness to Michael Carrick, in which only Matt Busby and Alex Ferguson truly tamed the Old Trafford job.

Photograph: Manchester United v Everton, 2 October 2021 (28)

Michael Carrick's struggles in interim charge at Manchester United fit a pattern stretching back a century, according to an analysis by Guardian Football, which argues that only Matt Busby and Alex Ferguson have ever fully mastered the club in the past 100 years.

The piece notes that Bruno Fernandes and Lisandro Martínez gave television interviews that undermined Carrick, episodes it frames as consistent with United's long tradition of player unrest destabilising managers.

Fernandes was left out of the matchday squad against Bournemouth and sat in the stands in club tracksuit, a decision the article likens to the kind of man-management employed by Ferguson during his own tenure.

Guardian Football runs through the club's managerial casualties since Busby. Wilf McGuinness was sacked in December 1970, with Brian Kidd reportedly telling teammates, "You lousy bastards, you let him down." Frank O'Farrell departed after a 5-0 defeat to Crystal Palace at Selhurst Park in December 1972, having earlier had to ask Busby to vacate the manager's office. O'Farrell later described Busby's inner circle as "a fantasy world" and said "there was no reality in the myth."

Tommy Docherty was dismissed in 1977 following an affair with the club physiotherapist's wife, the news delivered by club secretary Les Olive. Dave Sexton lost his job in 1981 despite winning his final seven matches, undone by falling attendances. Ron Atkinson was sacked in November 1986, shortly before Ferguson's arrival.

The article highlights how Ferguson's successors have had to operate in his continuing shadow. It cites his 2021 remark to mixed martial artist Khabib Nurmagomedov, "You should always start with your best players," made after Ole Gunnar Solskjær dropped Cristiano Ronaldo, as evidence of his lingering influence. Ferguson's stipend from the club, reported at £2m annually, was ended by Sir Jim Ratcliffe in 2024.

Louis van Gaal's exit after the 2016 FA Cup final win is also recalled, with Van Gaal saying his wife learned of his sacking from club staff before he did. Guardian Football notes executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward had described Van Gaal on his appointment as someone people know as "a larger-than-life character."

The piece concludes that attempts by the Glazer family's administration and, since December 2023, Ratcliffe's Ineos to professionalise the club have repeatedly run into United's entrenched internal culture, the same forces now closing in on Carrick.

Photo credits

File photo (2021). Photo: Ardfern · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails