Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Lahm says Manchester City's rule-breaking risks football's grassroots ties

Writing for Guardian Football, former Germany captain Philipp Lahm argues Manchester City's Premier League financial breaches show why strict enforcement and Germany's 50+1 ownership model matter for football's future.

Pep Guardiola on the touchline during a Manchester City Premier League match
AI-generated illustration

Former Germany captain Philipp Lahm has used a column for Guardian Football to argue that Manchester City's breach of Premier League financial regulations threatens football's connection to its grassroots, even as he praised the club's football and the coaching of Pep Guardiola.

City were found guilty of breaching Premier League financial rules between 2009 and 2018, having allegedly invested almost €1bn more than they declared and were permitted to spend. The club face the possibility of forced relegation or having titles stripped, though City deny wrongdoing and are appealing against the decision.

Lahm wrote that he had always admired Guardiola's work, describing City under him as a finely tuned unit whose play he could recognise purely from the passing patterns and spacing between players. He credited Guardiola with inspiring a generation of coaches, naming Vincent Kompany, Mikel Arteta and Enzo Maresca, and suggesting Ilkay Gündogan and Rodri could follow.

He pointed out that City long avoided the very biggest transfer targets, instead developing players such as Kevin De Bruyne after his release by Chelsea, Rodri after his talent went underappreciated in Madrid, Gündogan after injury setbacks, and Gianlugi Donnarumma once he was no longer wanted by Paris Saint-Germain. He also noted signings from Hamburg, Frankfurt and Wolfsburg, and said Erling Haaland in 2022 was the first City target also being chased by Bayern Munich.

On that basis, Lahm argued City did not behave as Paris Saint-Germain had done before the Luis Enrique era, and were not markedly different in recruitment strategy from roughly ten other leading European clubs. But he said that did not excuse rule-breaking, and backed the Premier League's effort to police unfair competition.

Lahm contrasted this with Germany's 50+1 rule, under which the non-profit parent section of a club must retain majority voting rights, recently upheld by the federal cartel office. Exceptions granted to Leverkusen and Wolfsburg remain under review. He said the rule balances outside investment with fan participation and may explain why average attendances in Germany are higher than anywhere else in the world.

He also welcomed Uefa's resistance to Fifa president Gianni Infantino's push to privatise the World Cup and its profits, and criticised Infantino's role, alongside Donald Trump, in the lifting of Folarin Balogun's suspension, which Lahm said many in football saw as a breach of normal process. He said the resulting outcry made it possible Infantino's position could be under threat.

Lahm concluded that punishing rule-breaking at clubs such as City and within Fifa is necessary to keep elite football tied to its grassroots, arguing that such enforcement is best carried out by a non-profit body like Uefa rather than a commercial one.