Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

US Sports

Rollins says analytics undervalue clubhouse chemistry in MLB

Phillies great Jimmy Rollins tells Front Office Sports that front-office number-crunching misses the camaraderie driving the Chicago White Sox's playoff run.

Photograph taken by Googie Man 00:43, 16 August 2007 . . Googie man . . 1271×1500 (1,592,080 bytes)

Former Philadelphia Phillies shortstop Jimmy Rollins says Major League Baseball's analytics departments are undervaluing clubhouse chemistry when building rosters, pointing to the Chicago White Sox's postseason run as evidence.

Rollins, who is part of TBS's studio coverage for the American League Division Series and American League Championship Series, made the comments in an interview with Front Office Sports, as reported by Yahoo Sports.

Asked whether chemistry has become undervalued amid the rise of analytics in roster construction, Rollins replied simply: "100%."

He said a team can be assembled on paper to look like the best in the league, only to fail because the players do not get along once they reach the clubhouse.

Rollins argued that executives without playing experience cannot quantify team spirit, recalling a hypothetical exchange with analytics staff: "Where'd you go to college? I went to the college of MLB. Where'd you go?"

He drew a direct comparison between the current White Sox team and the 2006 Phillies, a side he played on that outperformed the front office's own timeline for reaching the playoffs.

Rollins said he and former Phillies teammate Ryan Howard discussed the parallel while golfing, recalling the attitude in that Phillies clubhouse: "Why not us? Why can't we? I don't care what they say, but why can't we? We have enough. We're good enough. We're hungry enough."

He described the current White Sox squad, not expected to contend, as playing with freedom rather than pressure, saying the team's mindset amounts to: "We have nothing to lose and everything to gain."

Rollins pointed to lighthearted moments around infielder Miguel Vargas, whom he said teammates teased for being interviewed by himself, Pedro Martinez and Curtis Granderson, as a sign of the group's ease under the spotlight.

He called the White Sox "America's team right now" in his interview, contrasting their loose approach with teams whose high payrolls bring built-in expectations to win.

Turning to the New York Yankees, Rollins said the club has camaraderie but lacks the same enjoyment, telling Front Office Sports: "So they're interesting, and I think they have camaraderie. I don't think they have the joy."

He attributed that difference to the Yankees being expected to win every season, an expectation he said is impossible to meet consistently but remains the standard the organisation is held to.

Photo credits

File photo (2007). Photo: User Googie man on en.wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails