Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Grealish's discipline problems expose gulf with football's new era

Jack Grealish's suspension at Everton and continued omission from England duty highlight how far the game has shifted from the maverick culture he once embodied, Guardian Football reports.

Jack Grealish in action for Everton during the 2025-26 Premier League season
AI-generated illustration

Jack Grealish has never been picked by Thomas Tuchel for England, despite the manager once saying he loved "everything about" the forward, Guardian Football reports.

When Tuchel left Grealish out of his first squad in March 2025, the explanation given was that "he simply has no rhythm". Little has improved since.

Everton suspended the 31-year-old for three matches this season over what the club called "a breach of club discipline". Speculation that his loan from Manchester City could be terminated early was played down by the Everton manager, David Moyes.

Grealish returned in a behind-closed-doors friendly against Derby last week and posted an apology on Instagram, writing: "I want to apologise to the fans and everyone at the club for not being able to help the team the last few weeks."

His career remains, by most measures, a successful one. He went from boyhood hero at Aston Villa, central to the club's revival, to a club-record £100m move to City and a Champions League, Premier League and FA Cup treble.

Unlike Declan Rice, who faced hostility in the Republic of Ireland for choosing England over the country of his youth representation, Grealish has avoided becoming a pariah figure there despite making the same switch.

At City, though, he was often described as a functional part of Pep Guardiola's system rather than the free-flowing individual who drew comparisons with England's long line of ball-carrying mavericks, from Len Shackleton and Stan Bowles to Charlie George and Tony Currie.

Those players, celebrated in Rob Steen's 1995 book The Mavericks, were prized, in Steen's words, because "they embraced risk, because they dared not to give a damn, because, most of all, they dared on our behalf".

That culture has largely disappeared from the top of the English game. Brighton's manager, Fabian Hürzeler, explained on Sunday the regime required of a player such as Pascal Gross to stay effective in the Premier League: "So much work in the shadows, recovery, preparation."

Modern elite players are expected to maintain body-fat levels of between 8% and 12% and sleep for eight to 10 hours a night, a world removed from the "refuelling habits" Graham Taylor once attributed, euphemistically, to Paul Gascoigne.

Jadon Sancho's situation underlines how unforgiving the market has become for unfulfilled talent. Despite Europa League and Conference League winners' medals and a Champions League final appearance, the 26-year-old remains without a club since leaving Manchester United.

Harry Kane, by contrast, has become the reference point for discipline rewarded. Kane and Grealish both emerged in the 2014-15 season, Kane at Tottenham Hotspur and Grealish leading Villa to the FA Cup final, with Grealish then regarded in Birmingham and Irish youth football circles as the greater natural talent.

Receiving the Ballon d'Or last month at the London Palladium, Kane was praised by Thierry Henry, who said: "Harry Kane is a perfect example that work ethic is a talent, working hard is talent, not only pure skill … this guy had to suffer." Henry's remarks drew criticism for being seen as elitist.

Guardian Football notes the echo of the 1970s, when flair players such as Bowles and Charlie George, capped five and one times respectively by England, were overlooked by the pragmatic managers Alf Ramsey and Don Revie in favour of a more disciplined approach, a path later followed by Kevin Keegan after George Best's decline.