Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Guardian readers rewrite its shirt-number tribute list for footballers

After Guardian Football picked 50 players synonymous with their shirt numbers, readers submitted their own additions and corrections, from Aberdeen's No 0 to Roy Keane's No 16.

Collage of footballers readers nominated as best associated with their shirt numbers
AI-generated illustration

Guardian Football published a list last week of 50 footballers judged to have become inseparable from the number on their back. Readers responded with their own nominations, filling gaps the original selection left open and stretching the list from No 0 to No 51.

One reader, Lewis, pointed to Aberdeen's Zerouali as an honourable mention for No 0, a number rarely issued in Scottish football before the rules changed, and noted the player died young in a car crash.

The biggest omission readers identified was at No 1. David Cronin argued the original piece overlooked Bert Trautmann, the former German prisoner of war who became a Manchester City goalkeeping legend after starting out with a camp team and then St Helens. Trautmann made more than 500 appearances for City, including the closing 17 minutes of the 1956 FA Cup final with a broken neck, and became the first goalkeeper named Footballer of the Year, saving 60% of the penalties he faced. Citizenship rules meant he was never capped internationally. Lev Yashin, by Cronin's account, once said: "my only equal is the German boy at Manchester City."

At No 4, Nick Ramage nominated Billy Bremner as the player who embodied Leeds United's identity under manager Don Revie for more than a decade as captain of club and country. He noted only fellow Scot Gordon Strachan came close while wearing the same shirt, recalling the words on Strachan's statue outside Elland Road: "Side before self, every time."

Kevin R Cox put forward Billy Wright for No 5, recalling how Wolverhampton Wanderers manager Stan Cullis converted him from wing-half to centre-half despite his modest height, before Wright captained England and became the first player in the world to win 100 caps, also leading Wolves to a notable victory over Honved.

Tim Evans backed Bobby Moore for No 6, citing Pelé's description of the West Ham United captain as the best defender he faced, while John Heath made the case for Stanley Matthews at No 7, crediting the winger with reviving Stoke City on his return to the club in the 1960s after spells including Blackpool.

Richard Hirst argued the original list's failure to include either Pelé or Lionel Messi at No 10 was its most glaring omission, calling one of the two the definitive choice for the number.

Further down the list, a reader highlighted Roy Keane as the player most associated with No 16, pointing to his effectiveness in midfield battles, including the contest against Zinedine Zidane in Turin's Stadio delle Alpi, as a counterpoint to his later reputation as a television pundit.