Giants mailbag: Banks extension talk grows as Dart injury limits run game
Big Blue View's mailbag column addresses a possible Tae Banks contract extension, the Giants' run-game struggles without Jaxson Dart, and competition on the offensive line.

The New York Giants could consider a contract extension for cornerback Tae Banks if his strong form continues, according to Big Blue View's mailbag column, which noted a projected franchise tag figure of $23.119 million for cornerbacks, sourced to Over The Cap.
Columnist Ed Valentine wrote that an extension for Banks would have seemed unlikely before the season began, but that an improved attitude alongside his on-field performance has changed that outlook. He suggested a deal of a couple of years could be realistic, with 13 games still to play before any decision is made.
The Giants sit at 3-1, and the mailbag addressed whether that start changes the team's approach to in-season roster additions. Valentine said the club remains reluctant to give up significant resources for short-term fixes, preferring young players who could stay for several years, though he acknowledged the open state of the NFC East increases the temptation to make a move.
Much of the mailbag focused on the team's run-game difficulties. Valentine attributed them primarily to the absence of quarterback Jaxson Dart rather than any drop-off from fullback Patrick Ricard. Dart carried the ball 11 times for 54 yards, a 4.9-yard average, in the season opener, and his 22-yard run that day remains the longest of the season for the Giants. No running back has produced a carry longer than 13 yards since.
Valentine described Cam Skattebo and Najee Harris as power runners unlikely to generate the explosive plays Dart's scrambling ability once provided, and said Tyrone Tracy is the closest thing the roster has to a big-play threat, suggesting he may see more opportunities.
On the offensive line, the mailbag referenced a Big Blue View fan survey in which 71 per cent backed Bryan Hudson over John Michael Schmitz at centre. Valentine said he expects the Giants to move on from Schmitz after this season and believes Hudson should be given enough playing time to determine whether he is capable of taking over.
The mailbag also touched on quarterback J.J. McCarthy's role, with Valentine saying increased use of McCarthy would allow the Giants to run parts of the playbook that starter Jameis Winston cannot execute as effectively.
A separate question addressed why no extra-point attempt followed a late touchdown by Banks in the Giants' game against the Arizona Cardinals. Valentine explained that a rule change introduced in 2018 means an extra point is not required when it would not affect the outcome of the game, noting that total points scored ranks low among the league's playoff tiebreakers.
Photo credits
File photo (2025). Photo: All-Pro Reels · CC BY-SA 4.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails