Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

England beat Spain 3-2 in Madrid, echoing Southgate's 2018 Seville win

A 3-2 victory over Spain in the Nations League has revived memories of a near-identical scoreline from 2018, but Guardian Football cautions against reading too much into it.

James (Jimmy) Anderson at Headingley, warming up with the England squad ahead of the third Ashes Test against Australia. Anderson did not play in the match

England came from 3-0 up to beat Spain 3-2 at the Riyadh Air Metropolitano Stadium in Madrid, a Nations League result that Guardian Football's Barney Ronay says deserves context rather than instant celebration.

Spain had conceded three goals at home in a competitive men's international only once before Sunday's defeat, and that earlier occasion was also a 3-2 loss to England, in Seville on 15 October 2018, under Gareth Southgate.

The parallels extend beyond the scoreline. Southgate had been in permanent charge for 684 days and had overseen 28 previous matches, including a narrow World Cup semi-final defeat, when his side won in Seville. Thomas Tuchel had been in post for 683 days and taken charge of 27 earlier fixtures, also following a narrow World Cup semi-final loss, when his team won in Madrid.

Ronay's column, published by Guardian Football, notes that England's first-half display in Madrid saw Spain not merely outmuscled but outplayed, with the visitors reduced to complaining about fouls and unable to regain possession in tight areas.

The piece warns that the 2018 Seville result did not herald a lasting shift. England followed it with 27 goals in six games that autumn, including wins by 6-0, 7-0 and 4-0, built around a midfield of Harry Winks, Ross Barkley and Eric Dier, and a forward line of Raheem Sterling, Harry Kane and Marcus Rashford.

That momentum did not survive the disruption caused by the pandemic. England went 42 weeks without a fixture, and by November 2020 were losing 2-0 in Belgium while playing with a back five and a deep defensive midfield, with the European Championship already postponed a year.

Southgate's side went on to reach the final of that tournament in 2021, losing to Italy after starting the match with a back five alongside Declan Rice and Kalvin Phillips, a setup Ronay describes as congealing under pressure as the game reached its decisive stages.

Guardian Football's argument is that Sunday's win in Madrid cannot by itself be read as a breakthrough for Tuchel's England, given how the earlier Seville victory eventually gave way to caution and a more conservative approach rather than sustained progress.

The comparison is offered as a lesson rather than a prediction, with the piece stressing that history shows no guaranteed route from a single victory over Spain to long-term success, even as England's talent is acknowledged as sufficient to challenge for the home European Championship in two years' time.

Photo credits

File photo (2019). Photo: Ben Sutherland · CC BY 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons