Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Athletics & Cycling

Cyclingnews staff split over legitimacy of virtual cycling races

In an editors' roundtable published by Cyclingnews, staff disagreed sharply on whether indoor esports cycling should be regarded as genuine racing or merely a fitness test.

A cyclist riding on an indoor smart trainer set up for virtual racing
AI-generated illustration

Cyclingnews gathered its editorial team for a roundtable debate on whether virtual cycling contests, held on platforms such as Zwift, deserve to count as genuine competition, publishing the discussion as part of the outlet's Indoor Cycling Week coverage.

The piece noted that the esports discipline has expanded significantly in recent years. A rainbow jersey is now awarded for it, and the UCI Esports World Championship held its first edition in December 2020. Cyclingnews also pointed out that prize funds in the virtual events can be substantial.

Several contributors argued that virtual competition cannot be equated with events on the road. Assistant Features Editor Matilda Price asked, "Is there a treadmill world championship?", arguing that indoor contests strip away tactics, positioning and genuine skill, and fail as a spectator event.

Managing Editor Laura Weislo took a similar view, comparing the indoor discipline to swimming rather than road cycling. She said, "Virtual racing, as Matilda already pointed out, is racing in the way a swim meet is racing," adding that elements such as cornering, descending and physical contact between riders are absent online.

Senior Tech Writer Will Jones was equally dismissive, calling it "Indoor racing is sanitised nonsense" and likening it to rowing on a gym machine rather than on open water, arguing that cycling without handling skills amounts to little more than a fitness test.

NA Production Editor Jackie Tyson questioned whether an indoor trainer could ever be considered a race machine, noting there is no virtual world championship in disciplines such as cross-country skiing or biathlon, and arguing that a stationary bike cannot form a true peloton.

Other staff members pushed back. Staff Writer Owen Rogers said, "Of course, virtual racing is real racing," explaining that he no longer competes on the road but found online competition against riders of similar physical ability more suited to him, having tried it once while testing a power meter.

Associate Editor (Tech) Josh Croxton also defended the format, arguing that if "racing on Zwift isn't real racing, then neither is Mario Kart", while accepting it is not a spectator sport in the way events on the road are.

The debate reflected a broader divide among the Cyclingnews team over whether the growth of esports cycling, backed by UCI recognition and prize money, amounts to a genuine discipline or simply a structured way of measuring fitness indoors.