Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Football

Ballon d'Or's history exposes award's enduring individual-versus-team puzzle

Guardian Football traces the Ballon d'Or back to Stanley Matthews' contested 1956 triumph as this year's shortlist again splits opinion ahead of Monday's ceremony.

Harry Kane in a game against Colchester United in the FA Cup.

Monday's Ballon d'Or ceremony will revive a debate as old as the award itself: how to single out one player from a sport that has been built around the collective since Milan beat Benfica 2-1 in the 1963 European Cup final, a game in which a cynical foul by Gino Pivatelli on Mário Coluna broke the Benfica playmaker's foot and, in effect, marked the arrival of systems football, according to Guardian Football's analysis.

That tension was present even before systems football took hold. When the award launched in 1956, Stanley Matthews won it at the age of 38 despite Blackpool finishing 11 points behind champions Manchester United and exiting the FA Cup in the third round, Guardian Football notes.

Overlooked that year were Duncan Edwards and Tommy Taylor of the title-winning United side, and Bert Trautmann, who won the Football Writers' player of the year after playing on with a broken neck in the FA Cup final as Manchester City lifted the trophy. Alfredo Di Stéfano had just inspired Real Madrid to the inaugural European Cup, Athletic Bilbao had won La Liga, Pivatelli had finished Serie A's top scorer, Giuliano Sarti had won the Scudetto with Fiorentina and Nikita Simonyan had powered Spartak Moscow to the Soviet title.

The Hungarian vote that year was split between Ferenc Puskás, József Bozsik and Sándor Kocsis, a problem that successful teams still face. The award came a month after the Hungarian uprising was crushed by Soviet tanks, with two of the three players in the process of defecting, which Guardian Football suggests made it just as well for organisers France Football that none of them won.

This year's race shows the same puzzle persists. Fabián Ruiz won the World Cup, the Champions League and Ligue 1 this season, yet would not be considered either Paris Saint-Germain's or Spain's outstanding player, underlining that the Ballon d'Or has never simply rewarded the biggest trophy haul.

Within PSG's front three, Ousmane Dembélé won last year's award, while Khvicha Kvaratskhelia was arguably the standout performer this season even though Georgia did not qualify for the World Cup. Neither Dembélé nor teammate Désiré Doué had a particularly notable tournament in that competition.

Arsenal's case is complicated in a different way. Guardian Football argues their Premier League title and run to the Champions League final may represent the greatest achievement by a European club last season, yet only three Arsenal players feature on the 30-man shortlist, and none of Gabriel, William Saliba or Declan Rice had standout World Cups.

Spain's World Cup win, built on the collective strength of their midfield with Rodri as its embodiment, raises the same question from another angle, particularly given Lamine Yamal was carrying an injury for the first few months of the year.

Photo credits

File photo. Photo: enviro warrior from england · CC BY-SA 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons · shown in full here; cropped in thumbnails