Search
Daily All In

Edition: English

Cricket

Agnew: Cummins' position as Australia captain in serious doubt

BBC cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew says he cannot see how Pat Cummins survives as Australia captain through to next summer's Ashes series as the sandpapergate scandal resurfaces.

James (Jimmy) Anderson at Headingley, warming up with the England squad ahead of the third Ashes Test against Australia. Anderson did not play in the match

Pat Cummins faces a fight to remain Australia captain beyond this winter, according to BBC cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew, as fresh claims over the 2018 ball-tampering scandal known as sandpapergate engulf the national team.

Cummins addressed the media on 12 November, describing claims made by Usman Khawaja relating to the affair as "100% wrong" and "utter nonsense". His agent has since repeated the captain's version of events.

The original scandal dates to a Test against South Africa in Cape Town in 2018, when Cameron Bancroft was caught using sandpaper on the ball. Steve Smith, the captain at the time, and David Warner were also found to have been involved, and all three were sanctioned.

Agnew writes that he has never found it plausible the Australian bowling attack of the day was unaware of what was happening, arguing that the ball is effectively the bowlers' tool and that a batsman such as Bancroft, then the least experienced player in the side, would not have tampered with it independently.

Cummins was the junior bowler in that 2018 team and has since risen to the captaincy. Agnew notes there is no indication at present that he intends to resign or that Cricket Australia plans to remove him, with the governing body continuing to back him publicly.

Cummins is scheduled to lead Australia in the first Test against New Zealand, beginning in Perth on 9 December. Agnew points out that the match falls in Bancroft's home city, in the state where a 4,000-word testimony from Bancroft on the affair was first published, and suggests the reaction of the Perth crowd to Cummins will be closely watched.

Looking further ahead, Agnew questions whether Cummins can still be in charge by the time the Ashes series opens at Trent Bridge on 18 June, saying he currently cannot envisage it given the scrutiny and crowd reaction the captain would face throughout an England tour.

Cummins has said he does not wish to discuss sandpaper again, a stance Agnew calls unrealistic given the likely intensity of questioning to come. One possible route out, Agnew suggests, would be for Cummins to step aside citing the toll of the controversy on his team and family rather than admitting any guilt — recent images have shown him being confronted outside his home in Australia.

Agnew adds that such a move could also ease pressure on other bowlers from that era, including Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, though he maintains that wider questions remain for Cricket Australia and others present in Cape Town in 2018, including former coach Darren Lehmann, now at Northamptonshire, and David Saker, who has recently worked with England. He also credits former Australia media manager Kate Hutchison with having raised concerns at the time about the risks the team was taking.

Photo credits

File photo (2019). Photo: Ben Sutherland · CC BY 2.0 · via Wikimedia Commons